Church Girl in Leather

[Verse 1] She was sipping club soda at a dive full of smoke Clutching her coat like a holy cloak Eyes wide open but begging to stray Said, “I shouldn’t be here” — I said, “Come anyway” I traced her guilt with my fingertip Told her, “God won’t see if you don’t slip” She said, “I’ve never…” — I said, “I know” Then laid her down like a holy ghost [Chorus] She was grace, I was pressure She came in white, left in pleasure Bent her faith ‘til it snapped like a seam Now she’s my church girl in a leather dream Taught her sin in silk and chain Every “no” just fed the flame She swore she’d never — now she begs for more My little disciple on all fours [Verse 2] Her prayers turned to moans when the leather hit skin She flinched at first, then asked to begin Whispered “is this what damnation feels like?” I kissed her hard and said, “Only if it’s right” The rope was soft, but the edge was real Every knot she took, I made her feel She begged me “don’t stop” with heaven in her eyes And sin wrapped sweet between her thighs [Chorus] She was grace, I was pressure She came in white, left in pleasure Bent her faith ‘til it snapped like a seam Now she’s my church girl in a leather dream Taught her sin in silk and chain Every “no” just fed the flame She swore she’d never — now she begs for more My little disciple on all fours [Verse 3] Sweat on her altar, lace torn apart She wore my bite marks close to her heart “Say a prayer,” I teased, hand on her throat She gasped, “for what?” — I said, “to cope” I pushed her limits, she pulled me near Her faith gave out but her voice rang clear She came for shame but stayed for the thrill And now she wants more — and I always will [Bridge] Get on your knees, forget the prayer You’re not looking for God — I’m already there No shame, no halo, no need to pretend You wanted the edge — I gave you the end [Final Chorus] She was grace, I was pressure She came in white, left in pleasure Bent her faith ‘til it snapped like a seam Now she’s my church girl in a leather dream Taught her sin in silk and chain Every “no” just fed the flame She swore she’d never — now she begs for more My little disciple on all fours